Definition: And one of you say unto them, Depart in peace, be [ye] warmed and filled; notwithstanding ye give them not those things which are needful to the body; what [doth it] profit?

Explanation: Okay, let’s break down this verse from James 2:16. It’s a really important one that gets at a core idea about generosity and true importance. Here's a simplified explanation: The Basic Idea: This verse is asking a question: “If you’re offering someone something, but they don’t really need it, does it even matter?” It’s essentially saying, “Does giving out without considering someone else’s needs truly make a difference?” Let's unpack it word by word: “And one of you say unto them…” – This is James speaking to someone who is offering something – perhaps help, kindness, or even just a smile. “…Depart in peace, be [ye] warmed and filled; notwithstanding ye give them not those things which are needful to the body.” – This is the tricky part. “Depart in peace” means to offer with goodwill and without judgment. "Be warmed and filled" suggests that the person receiving the gift should feel good and happy. The phrase "Notwithstanding" (which translates roughly to “though,” or “even though”) is key here. It’s saying, even if you are offering something, it doesn't really matter if they receive it. “What [doth] it profit?” – This is the question James is asking. "Profit?" Here, it means "what good does it do?" or “What benefit does it bring?” Putting it all together - A Simple Explanation: James is suggesting that when we give to others, especially those who are struggling or in need, it’s much more valuable and meaningful than simply giving out without considering their needs. It's like a gift – it brings joy to the giver, but it also brings happiness and benefit to the receiver. The Core Message: The verse is about true generosity . It’s not just about giving, but about giving with a genuine desire to help others and make them feel good. It's about prioritizing their well-being over our own comfort or expectation of a return. In essence, James is saying that the impact of our giving isn’t in how much we give, but in how we give – with kindness and consideration for another person’s needs. --- Do you want me to: Explain this verse further in more detail? Give a real-life example to illustrate the point? Connect it to other Bible verses?